|
Builder Resources
Engine Choices
Photos
Tools
Stories
FAQ's
Commercial Sites
Newbies
Corner
Email:
moderator@CH601.org
| |
Jon Croke's 701


NTSB Identification: CHI04LA014
14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
Accident occurred Thursday, October 16, 2003 in brussels, WI
Aircraft: Croke Zenith CH 701, registration: N701US
Injuries: 1 Uninjured.
On October 16, 2003, at 1800 central daylight time, a Croke Zenith CH701,
N701US, collided with trees during a forced landing one-quarter mile south of
the pilot's private airstrip in Brussels, Wisconsin. The pilot was not injured.
The airplane was substantially damaged. The 14 CFR Part 91 personal flight was
being conducted in visual meteorological conditions without a flight plan. The
local flight originated from the private airstrip at 1730.
The pilot reported that after a local flight he came back to the airstrip to
land. He stated he was not happy with the approach so he decided to go-around.
He reported that engine did not produce enough power during the go-around to
maintain altitude. The airplane settled into trees in a wooded area off the
south end of the 1,000 foot long airstrip.
|
Match:
|
#11 |
|
Message:
|
#25865 |
The cat is out of the bag! I was laying low about this incident because I
am so EMBARASSED about what happened! But, in light of the participation in
this list of all the good people that help make plane building possible, I
will bear my soul and explain what happened. You might say that it could help
someone else avoid a similar mistake someday... but I doubt anyone would do
something as foolish as what I did....! Here's the story (BTW, the NTSB did an
excellent job describing the incident.... I had to dust off that big FAR/AIM
book to look up my obligations after a crash... you
indeed are supposed to report this to them. An hour after I talked to
them on the phone it was on the web.... I thought few would read it and
'discover' my mishap..!) Had 2.5 hrs on the plane... flies GREAT! Was really
starting to experiment with flight characteristics, etc. Was preparing to land
at my home strip (1000' grass) and decided to do a go-around because I was off
a bit.. Well, upon giving it full throttle, I realized that for the first time
ever it only went to about 4000 rpm, instead of 5200 or so. She just barely
made it over the high tension wires at the end of my strip and really wasnt
climbing much at this engine speed. Quick glance over the dials indicated no
abnormal temps or pressures.... throttled it down and then back up again but
still only about 4000. NO hesitation, or stumble... smooth but not enough
power. Now there is a heavily forested area beyond the high tension wires and
I saw the tree tops coming at me. Kept it above stall speed and prayed for the
engine to 'kick-in' to high power, but the tree tops quickly grabbed my
wheels. An immediate and fast nose dive down into the trees (altitude approx
50') resulted. I kept my eyes open and wondered how bad this was going to be.
The sound of a million beer cans being crushed reverberated as I spun almost
straight down thru the branches. I n moments I found myself stopped just short
of the ground (I think it is still resting on 1 wheel on the ground) as the
last set of branches actually prevented impact into the ground. Absolute quiet
as the engine stopped on the way down (some tree trimming by GSC props for
sure!) I had NOT A SCRATCH on me or bruise of any sort. I pushed my way out
the passenger door as the attitude of the plane still sits at about 45 degrees
and titled. It was an AMAZING stroke of luck to be so gently brought to earth
without injury, if you think about it! The plane is trashed, (substantial
damage) but there are lots of parts that can be saved for the rebuild!
Probably lost the engine to a prop strike... but will pay a mechanic to
confirm (crankshaft twist??) Any bets as to whether it will be salvagable?
Wood prop hitting wood tree! Maybe. The FAA came out and looked at the wrecked
and agreed with me on my diagnosis of the cause of the accident.....! They
said I could still use the airworthy certif and rebuild from scratch with no
new registration! (maybe an inspection and entry in the logbook!) So hear
comes the EMBARASSING part.... I made a STUPID modification that caused this
accident. I just wasnt thinking at the time... I really am not TRYING to get
into the DARWIN club....While testing the engine before I ever finished the
plane, I was unhappy on how strong those carb throttle
springs were... they would always slowly pull my throttle faster and faster
from idle and I thought this to be a safety problem. I tightened the
friction of the throttle rod to the point that it was too tight for me... so
I fixed it once and for all.... I replaced those stiff
springs with GENTLER springs! B A D!!! It solved the runaway throttle
problem.. but... they were so gentle in their pull (look at your 912 if
this is not clear) esp weak at the last of their travel (full throttle). A
minor bind in the cables and those springs did not have
the strength to pull the throttle full open. Also, notice the design of
how the cables are attached...pushing the throttle to full power does NOT push
the cable, but relies entirely on those springs for
their movement. If I had a longer runway, this would have been a non
event. if.. if... if... Well the good news is that I look forward to start
building again because building should be less stressful 2nd time around...
and, knowing how FUN that thing flew will keep me going. Obviously, there is a
small money problem (no insurance) so will take it one step at a time. Im glad
I didnt sell my Kolb Firestar.. I can still fly! Here's the big story: I dont
think its an 'accident' that I walked away from a crash
like this w/o injury... that plane is engineered GREAT. It is SAFE and
STRONG and protected me all the way down. Chris Heintz saved my butt in spite
of myself.. seatbelts held, etc. I think I exploited its STOL capability to
the max! From full flight speed to dead stop in a matter of a few horizontal
feet! I live in a very small town and was hoping no one saw me go down....
sorry, but my neighbor saw it happen and called 911 and what I didnt know was
how many people have radio scanners.... the WHOLE town knows about this and I
have been in 'hiding' a bit... glad to be out of town this week. This
weekend I get the generator and sawzall and go out to
the crash site and make smaller parts out to the wreck to get them out
of there (neighbor's field). BTW, the FAA wants fotos of
my carb spring switch so they can do slide presentations at safety
seminars to show how foolishness can ruin your day! Look forward to remaining
on this list as I start over in the building process... but this time a bit
wiser! Thanks to all of you for your support! Jon (the aluminum butcher from
Brussels) Brussels, Wisconsin (near Green Bay)
|